For those with a very high tolerance for pain, here are (as of 10:00am Pacific today) 27 pages of discussion on this subject. I wish I was kidding. I've been reading it because there's a lot of good opinions and feedback there, but dear heaven is it painful.
But the discussion is covering all the major points, so kudos to the Kugu contributors there. Someone even brought up the specter of "super carrier small gang PvP." We're not very far from that as it is.
On the topic of nuking JBs entirely, one of my alliance-mates provided an amusing Assistant to the Quote of the Week:
Eve is already "Are We There Yet" Online.