His idea of allowing people to up-vote their choices broke badly, with some people trying to influence the results in their favor by up-voting their own submissions and down-voting others. So he asked me to come up with a list of who I would pick if I were going to judge. It's something I didn't mind doing, so I read through all seven pages of entries and picked ones that I liked for his two categories: serious entries and funny entries. Here's what I sent him:
|1st: Hallan Turrek||Eve Online: Reflections|
|2nd: Silentskills||EVE Online: Rebirth|
|3rd: Libria Kyzal||EvE: Promisius|
|1st: cryingblood||Eve Online : The Sims Expansion Pack|
|2nd: David Grogan||Eve Online - The Nex Generation|
|2nd: Sahara Sena||EVE: The NEX Generation|
|3rd: RipardTeg||EVE Online: The Hangover|
|Closest to what CCP will actually use, I think:|
|DangerosoDavo||Eve Online: Adapt|
For my first serious choice, I really like "Reflections". I like the double- and triple-meaning of it, particulary for this expansion, which is going to be about dichotomies: spaceships vs avatars, Empire vs null-sec, subcaps vs supercaps. Though "Dichotomies" might be a good name too, come to think of it. ;-) "Rebirth" as a second choice is obvious -- that's what CCP hopes this is what the winter expansion represents. "Promisius" struck me as the sort of almost-nonsense word that CCP might go for, and of course is a variation of "promises." And making those is what CCP has really been about this year...
For the funny ones, not much to say about them except those choices made me laugh. I wasn't sure who posted "The NeX Generation" first. And yes, I picked myself for third. Deal with it. ;-) I still think mine was pretty funny. I subtitled it: "Whoops! We got drunk and forgot where we put our space ships." But yeah, I like "The Sims Expansion Pack" the most. That one actually made me laugh out loud. A couple of others made me giggle: "EVE Online: Eyjafjallajokull", referencing Iceland's famous volcano, did. So did "EVE Online: Springtime for Hilmar". I'm sometimes a sucker for puns, and that one was really clever. But both of those options were probably too clever to actually pick.
That said, I think DangerosoDavo is probably closest to what CCP will actually name the expansion. The word "Adapt" brings up all sorts of mental images of where CCP wants to go with this expansion, and it's a good strong marketing word and throws a lot of subliminal messages at the player base, to boot.
Be interesting to see what CCP actually decides to go with! And it'll be interesting to see how Riverini decides to choose his winners as well. ;-)